Is Smith and Cross rum a good suggestion for my Jamaican friend?

I live in Canada where we don’t have a great selection of alcohol. I have a Jamaican friend who likes Wray & Nephew (as do I, though I can’t drink it straight like him yet haha) Smith and Cross has just hit our shelves and i bought it and tried it in a drink and loved it. I was just wondering if it was a good rum to suggest for him if he likes Wray since it’s the closest thing to that here really.

What do you need?

Find people, places and things. We'll ask thousands of Jamaicans to help you.


Smith and Cross isn’t sold in Jamaica as far as I know, so most Jamaicans wouldn’t know it. I’ve tried it and liked it, but it’s pretty different from W&N… that said, you’re right that it’s probably the most similar to W&N of options you have. The most similar rums to Wray are Rum-Bar Overproof, Rum Fire, Charley’s JB, JBW, or Monymusk…. but those are usually harder to find overseas than Wray and Nephew itself.


Correct, Smith & Cross is distilled in Jamaica (Hampden Estates) but unfortunately not sold there. It doesn’t have much in common with Wray & Nephew besides being overproof, in my opinion.

However, it is one of the few dark overproof rums on the market and among the best. (try it in a Jungle Bird sometime!)

Another solid dark overproof is Plantation OFTD (oh funk, that’s delicious) although it is not 100% Jamaican rum.

Cheers! 🍹🇯🇲✌🏽


We like Wray & Nephew overproof, Appleton & Red Stripe.

Rum Bar rum is acceptable to drink at an all inclusive party that is sponsored by rum bar - because its literally the only thing there is to drink. Then we leave & buy Wray & Nephew or Appleton


It’s not about the taste of the rum per se. It’s about brand recognition & Jamaican pride. Same way Scotsmen don’t drink Irish whiskey- they drink scotch. Jamaica is infamous for Appleton or Wray & Nephew. There are other rums that are far superior but a yaadman nuh care


Just clarify wray and nephew is the mfg. Appleton I think is a subsidiary of Wray and Nephey. The way I’ve understood it is the overproof white rum that wray and Nephey makes with water is a great way to get drunk, cure a cold and tune a drum. Appleton is for when you want to sip and impress your friends

© 2022 Brawta List · Terms · Privacy · Contact us